February 19, 2004

High Definition TVs Under $1500: Quick Look

I spent a couple hours last evening in the local Best Buy trying to get my head around the dizzying selection of High Definition TV sets they had on display.

There were four different screen technologies on display. LCD, Plasma, Rear Projection, and CRT.

Here's my subjective assessment of the types after wandering among them for awhile.

Plasma and LCD has the sharpest, brighest picture quality. I thought Plasma was sharper, but one of the sales guys I spoke to thought LCD.

Both Plasma and LCD are by far the most pricey of all the types. And by extension, they offer the smallest screens for a comparable price.

Good old fashioned CRT, in a widescreen HDTV format, was very bright and had the widest good viewing angle. But the CRT sharpness was not much better than a really good pic from an "old-fashioned" signal.

Rear Projection, by far, the offers the best screen real-estate for your dollar. But the brighness is the lowest of the lot, and is viewable from the narrowest angles. Image sharpness was comparable to the CRT, but only when you're well centered in front of the screen.

My evalution of these sets will be an ongoing process, but here's a quick first look at the ones that were: widescreen, HDTV, and that had a base price of under $1,500. (Keep in mind that all of these sets had manufacturer's rebates of $100 or more, that will reduce the price.)

Mfgsizetypebase pricemod numdescrip
Philips17LCD100017PF9936WS FP LCD HDTV Mon
Samsung17LCD1000LTN1785WWS FP LCD HDTV Mon
Samsung30CRT1000TXN-3071WHWS HDTV
Philips30CRT90030PW850HWS HDTV
Philips34CRT150034PW850HWS HDTV
Mitsubishi42Rear Proj1500WT42313WS HDTV Mon
Toshiba42Rear Proj140042H83WS HDTV Mon
Toshiba46Rear Proj150046H83WS HDTV Mon
Panasonic47Rear Proj1500PT-47WX53WS HDTV Mon
RCA52Rear Proj1200D52W15WS HDTV Mon
Posted by jackhodgson at February 19, 2004 02:21 PM
Site Meter